Monday, September 29, 2014

Hold That Thought

"Casting down imaginations, and every high thing that exalts itself against the knowledge of God, and bringing into captivity every thought to the obedience of Christ" (II Corinthians 10:5).
In this article I want to look at three common philosophies of Christian music and share why I no longer hold these views.

Misconception #1. "It's the person's heart that matters, not the musical sounds. The music doesn't matter."

"A person's heart" is sort of a trump card in worship music debates. Contemporary Christian musicians have used this language for decades to validate every empty praise chorus and godless crossover song. "How can you judge this song? It came straight from the composer's heart. The artist is singing straight from the heart to the Lord." This is their blanket justification to do whatever they want to do, musically. I have now spent the better part of 25 years reconsidering this philosophy of worship and music.

The intentions and sincerity of our heart are very, very important. We cannot please God without a heart that believes that HE IS, and that He rewards those who come to Him (Psalm 24:3–5; Hebrews 11:6).

But the heart is also deceitful (Jeremiah 17:9). We can deceive even our own selves (James 1:21). False prophets and teachers deceive many people by selling them half-truths as The Truth. The Bible repeatedly warns us of this method of attack against God's people (Matthew 24:24, Colossians 2:8, II Peter 3:17, II Corinthians 11:13–15).

In music, as in all things, the heart is only one part of a much larger equation.

Jesus said that a person's heart is revealed by its fruit—by what comes out of his mouth. While we cannot judge a person's election of God, lest we be judged (Matthew 7:1), we can judge righteous judgment (John 7:24, I Corinthians 2:15–16). We can grow in grace and in the knowledge of the Lord Jesus Christ and, by the Word of God, exercise our senses to discern between good and evil (Hebrews 5:12–14).

I believe discerning between good and evil applies to music; not to judge a musician's heart or salvation, but to examine their Christian teaching/worship for truth and heresy. The Bible calls us to beware and be discerning of these things. What many people fail to understand is that music itself teaches us; that is, it shapes our thoughts and perspectives, as much as lyrics and lifestyles do. A musician's heart may be sincere and right with the Lord before his musical "doctrine" is fully shaped by the Word of God. The more we bend our hearts to know the Lord—by studying His Word and His creation—the more wisdom and knowledge we will have to discern the musical sounds and performance behaviors that reflect His ways and His character.

"For every tree is known by his own fruit. ... A good man out of the good treasure of his heart brings forth that which is good; and an evil man out of the evil treasure of his heart brings forth that which is evil: for of the abundance of the heart his mouth speaks. And why call ye me, Lord, Lord, and do not the things which I say?" (Luke 6:44-46).

Misconception #2. "Music is amoral. Musical sounds cannot convey a specific idea from musician to hearer in any way that could be judged as good or bad."

This is not absolutely true. Without saying a word, I can sit at a piano and make you smile, and probably laugh, within five minutes. You could even be blindfolded. I know how to tell universal (and clean) jokes through musical sounds. As a musician, I have the ability (with grave responsibility) to affect your attitude, your behavior, and your health through music. (What happens when you smile?)

To be clear, I am defining "musical sounds" as tonal phrases in the context of a piece of music, including but not limited to melody, harmony, and rhythm. Some people redefine "musical sounds" to mean an isolated note or chord, and then say that they can't judge whether an E-flat note or a C-natural chord conveys a particular message (What do you think?). But just as the letters of the alphabet and a list of random words hardly communicates an intelligent message, notes and chords are merely building blocks to musical communication. Breaking down music too far won't reveal more of the message of the musical tones, nor will it uncover the images, ideas, emotions, and morals that the music conveys and inspires.

I do agree that the message of music is, to some degree, subjective. We can't fully predict the exact outcome or results of a song on a hearer. Every individual receives the same song through a unique filter of his own spirituality, maturity, experiences, tastes, knowledge, personality, and physique. However, on a purely physiological level, sound waves are vibrations that cause sympathetic vibrations in other things. At this level, scientists have begun to measure music's impact and discover some predictable odds of emotional and behavioral responses to particular types of music. Even deaf people are affected by music.

Music has a powerful influence on people. It has a documented history, even in Scripture, of affecting a person's well-being and behavior (I Samuel 16:23; Luke 7:32, Matthew 11:17). Not even nothing is neutral or amoral before God (Matthew 25:26–27). In the end, we will be called to give an account for every idle word we speak and everything we do (or don't do) in this body (II Corinthians 5:10; Matthew 12:36, 25:45).

"For if the trumpet give an uncertain sound, who shall prepare himself to the battle?" (I Corinthians 14:8)

"Wherefore, if meat make my brother to offend, I will eat no flesh while the world standeth, lest I make my brother to offend" (I Corinthians 8:13).

Misconception #3. "I have no personal boundaries in music. I can't set limits on the immense variety of music in the world."

This is sandy ground on which many Christians have laid their musical foundation. I don't think they realize the full implications of what this means. Holding to "no boundaries in music" means they must reject or ignore all the principles and precepts in the Word of God that relate, directly or indirectly, to music and music-making.

Those would be boundaries.

As Christians, I know these men and women do have real boundaries in their lives and music, but they are reluctant to look for them and verbalize them. They are afraid of appearing narrow-minded or intolerant of others. They want to agree with everybody and alienate nobody. But this is an impossible position to hold in this world. Biblically inspired Christian principles will always polarize people, even professing believers. Polarization is even built into the gospel of Jesus Christ (Matthew 12:30, Luke 11:23).

"No boundaries" alienates me, because I have many boundaries in music that I can't lay aside for mere convenience. "No boundaries" includes some "Christian" music that I have had to repent of before the Lord—for taking His Name in vain and other sins. I have turned from those things and am not even considering going back. I am, however, always open to correction and adopting new boundaries that are founded on Christ-exalting biblical principles.

"For in many things we offend all. If any man offend not in word, the same is a perfect man, and able also to bridle the whole body" (James 3:2).

"Wherefore lay apart all filthiness and superfluity of naughtiness, and receive with meekness the engrafted word, which is able to save your souls. Therefore to him that knoweth to do good, and doeth it not, to him it is sin" (James 4:16–17).

Sunday, September 15, 2013

Three R’s of Biblical Worship Music

(Revised October 22, 2014)

If a worship song quotes the Bible, references the Bible, alludes to the Bible, it must be biblical. Yes?

If only it were that easy!

Lyrics that appear to come straight from Scripture may not actually communicate whole biblical truth. Scriptural song texts are often rewritten, edited, and styled to support anthropocentric (man-centered) religion. They serve to boost our egos, instead of increasing our understanding and reverence for God and His Word.

Unbiblical use of the Bible is no new thing. From the beginning, Satan has used half-truth and spiritual deception to mislead God’s people. He excels at misrepresenting the Word of God and raising doubts about God’s meaning (“Hath God said...?” Genesis 3:1). False doctrine almost always masquerades as real, incontrovertible truth—otherwise, it wouldn’t deceive us.

And Christian worship music is certainly not immune to his corruptive influence.

False teaching may not be immediate or obvious. Those who teach it may be deceived as well. It can even appear to help a generation of believers that first embraces it. But mishandling or misrepresenting God’s Word enables future generations to compromise His Truth in detrimental ways (cf., Numbers 21:9, II Kings 18:4).

So, how can we distinguish between a song that says something biblical and a song that is truly biblical in content?

Many Christian pastors, teachers, and musicians have offered various ways to evaluate worship music based on Scripture. Their biblical formulas, functions, and objectives for worship music are a great aid to true worship (John 4:23, I Corinthians 14:15). I would like to add some further thoughts to their already-rich pool of ideas.

The ultimate example and pattern for worship lyrics is the inspired poetry of the Bible itself. In the book of Psalms we find at least three keys to biblical worship lyrics:
  1. Biblical Roles — humbling our hearts to acknowledge and reverence God as our Creator, Ruler, and Lord.
  2. Biblical Reasons — exercising our minds to recall specific acts and merits of God’s holiness, righteousness, mercy, and victory.
  3. Biblical Righteousness — engaging our wills and instructing our emotions to return proper love and service for the glory of God.
Each of these keys is found in every Psalm in the Bible, though not always in this order. They provide a biblical framework for God-focused, God-honoring worship. A framework—as opposed to legalistic rules—can help blow away the chaff of self-absorbed praise, without stifling our individuality and creativity in writing new songs to the Lord.

Biblical Roles

How we view God will fundamentally shape our worship practices. The more we understand and submit to God’s role, as the only Creator and Ruler of the universe, the more biblically God-focused our worship will become.

The New Testament reveals a mystery: Jesus Christ is God the Lord. This is the gospel (cf. I John 5:20–21). We like to think the gospel is about us—“Jesus loves me and died for my sins”—but that is not “good news” apart from Who Jesus Is. What God has done in Christ Jesus is for His preeminent glory, not ours (Ephesians 2:4–10). He is superior in all things (Colossians 1:18).

The songs of the Bible use royal titles and noble attributes to identify God’s holy character and exalt His majesty. For example, Lord, Anointed, God, King, Priest, Redeemer, Savior, Protector, Judge.

We are not God. Seeing God in His high holiness gives the proper perspective of our own lesser role and responsibility as His creation—created in His image for His pleasure (Revelation 4:11); being conformed to the likeness of Christ (Romans 8:29), but not evolving into a higher life form (i.e., aspiring to be God; Isaiah 14:12–14; Genesis 3:5). God-honoring worship will always contain Psalm-like expressions of humanity’s lowliness, neediness, and humility as compared to the Lord.

God's people are not the world. The Psalms make a clear distinction between the godly versus the ungodly, the righteous and the unrighteous, God’s people and His enemies. These distinct roles are essential to rightly proclaim the gospel of the kingdom. The reality of the kingdom of God is that many are called, but few are chosen (Matthew 22:1–14). The Lord Jesus is the Savior of the world, but He is also the Judge of all the earth. The grace of God’s holy separation must be expressed in our hymnody, if we are to be true to the Word of God.

Remembering God’s preeminent role in the universe and our own lesser role as His creation, we are in the right place to recall the reasons why we worship Him.

Biblical Reasons

Biblically, there are three primary reasons we worship God. For:
  • His worth (name, disposition, and attributes),
  • His works (creation, redemption, and judgment), and
  • His Word (Living and written).  [Adapted from Paul S. Jones.]
The Bible offers no empty praise to God. Every statement of faith is backed by some reasoned justification of its truth. For example, look at the first song recorded in the Bible (Exodus 15):

. . . I will sing unto the Lord,
— Why?

For He has triumphed gloriously,
— What did He do?

The horse and his rider has He thrown into the sea.
— Why did you escape?

The LORD is my strength and song, and He has become my salvation:
He is my God, and I will prepare him an habitation [praise Him, Psalm 22:3];
my father’s God, and I will exalt Him.
— Who is this God?

The LORD is a man of war: the LORD is his name.
— What did He do again?

Pharaoh’s chariots and his host has He cast into the sea:
his chosen captains also are drowned in the Red sea.
— How did He do that?

Thy right hand, O LORD, is become glorious in power:
Thy right hand, O LORD, has dashed in pieces the enemy.
— (and so on)

A logical pattern of statement, rationale, and evidence is common to the worship songs of the Bible, whether it be a song of praise, prayer, or proclamation.

Because of the God we serve, we have more reasons to sing than we will ever be able to put into writing. There is no need for us to stoop to vague allusion or empty praise. If we don’t know how to be specific, now is the time to learn to sing with our understanding as well as with our mouths and our emotions (Psalm 47:7; I Corinthians 14:15).

Singing of and to God for the right reasons gives impetus and direction for a righteous response to God.

Biblical Righteousness

“For the righteous LORD loves righteousness . . .” (Psalm 11:7; 33:5).
“God commands self-denial, but the world makes that a reason of their standing off from the very grace of God in the gospel. God also commands that we be sober, chaste, humble, just, and the like; but the devil, and carnal hearts, make these very things the argument that keeps sinners from the word of salvation. Or rather take it thus; God forbids wickedness, because it is delightful to the flesh, and draws the heart from God, but therefore carnal men love wickedness and sin: Therefore they go on in sin, and ‘therefore they say unto God, Depart from us, for we desire no the knowledge of thy ways’ (Job 21:14; 22:15–17)” (John Bunyan, An Exposition on the First Ten Chapters of Genesis).
Righteousness is the mark of a believer in the Lord. By faith, we love the things that our God loves, and we abhor the things that He hates. We do the things our Lord tells us to do, and do not the things that He forbids. This is true grace and discipleship.

But we live in an age where “grace” is commonly preached without active “faith” and “works” (i.e., the fruit of righteousness). These three virtues—grace, faith, and works—are of God, and true worship, in spirit and in truth, is incomplete without them. We have no faith unless God gives it to us by grace (Ephesians 2:8). We have no righteousness without faith in the Lord Jesus Christ (Romans 1:17, 3:21–22, 4:5). We have no proof of our faith without good works (James 2:14–26; Matthew 11:28–30; John 15:10, 14).

This truth is clearly demonstrated in the songs of the Bible. The Psalms model the righteous actions, attitudes, comforts, and desires of God’s people. In every one of the biblical Psalms, the righteous are distinguished from the unrighteous in one or more ways, such as:

  • Declarations — “I will...” “I cried...” “I put...” 
  • Denunciations — “The ungodly are not so...” “The Lord shall have them in derision...” “The fool shall not stand...”
  • Descriptions — “Blessed are...” “His delight...” “The Lord will hear...” “His people...” “My enemies...”
  • Desires — “Lead me...” “Hear me...” “Have mercy...”
  • Directives — “Know...” “Be...” Serve...” “Stand...” “Praise...”
[Click here to download a color-coded sample from the Psalms showing these different ways in which the righteous are distinguished from the world.]

Biblical truth, rightly proclaimed, activates our wills and instructs our emotions to live unto God in a righteous manner: with reverent humility and obedient self-sacrifice for the glory of God.

A Biblical Framework

Certainly, we can see the value of each of these ingredients in worshiping the Lord. I have yet to meet a believer who objects to any one of them. But all three ingredients, used as a framework, can be painfully revealing.

It is surprising how much popular Christian music (old and new) is missing one or more of these keys. Many songs and hymns that seem to have strong biblical themes often fail to incorporate biblical roles, reasons, and righteousness in their expressed worship of the Lord. And many authors alter biblical texts for greater emotional impact—often at the expense of biblical understanding, perspective, and attitude.

Biblical worship in our casual, contemporary culture is neither simple nor easy, but our God is worthy of the greatest effort and the highest honors we can give Him. Christian songwriters and worship leaders cannot be too careful to prepare worship music that:
  • Acknowledges God’s ultimate authoritative role in our lives.
  • States specific reasons why we trust in God alone.
  • Models a reverent righteousness worthy of our thrice-holy Lord.
This is a very high standard—some would argue that it's an impossibly high standard that we couldn't possibly reach. But consider: If it is a consistent, biblical pattern, why would we not at least TRY to copy it?

Tuesday, June 4, 2013

What is the Gospel?

‎"The gospel is this: that we are more sinful and flawed in ourselves than we ever dared believe, yet at the very same time we are more loved and accepted in Jesus Christ than we ever dared hope" (Timothy Keller, The Meaning of Marriage).
Once again I find myself uncomfortable with Dr. Keller's definition of the Gospel. This "Gospel-centered" pastor always seems (to me) to miss the point.

We Christians have a funny way of abbreviating our way into squishy half-truths. For example, we talk about "The Book of Revelation" and the mystery of the prophecies it contains. And we talk about "The Gospel" and how God lovingly wraps His Band-Aid plan of salvation around our suffering world.

In doing so, we carelessly demote the central subject and object of our faith: the Lord Jesus Christ.

The Revelation of Jesus Christ is not about mapping a timeline of future events. Just so, the Gospel of Jesus Christ is NOT ABOUT US.

The Gospel of Jesus Christ
The Gospel does not revolve around people. It's not about how we feel. It's not about how we act. It's not about what we think. It's not about what we believe. The Gospel is not even primarily about what God does for us.

The biblical Gospel (good news) is Who God Is and how all of His acts display and confirm Who He Is. The Gospel is that God was in Jesus Christ (fully man and fully God), reconciling the world to Himself.

God created us for His pleasure, not ours.
He loves His creation for His sake, not ours.
He allows evil to accomplish His purposes, not ours.
He sacrificed Jesus for His satisfaction, not ours.
He gives us faith for His kingdom, not ours.
He judges the wicked for His honor, not ours.
He rewards the righteous for His glory, not ours.

It is God's supreme position over all His works and His utter holiness that cause us to bow down and worship.

We are convicted of sin by seeing God's perfection, not for believing we are "sinful and flawed in ourselves." We repent of sin because of His holy righteousness, not for the hope of "love and acceptance." And we love and do good (Does Keller's gospel include holy living?) because He left us an example, in Jesus Christ, that we should follow in His steps.

Is love and acceptance the best God that has to offer? If you're tailoring a gospel to my felt needs, you're going to have to do better than that. I can find love and acceptance by joining almost any club. What I may not be able to find in a club, however, is a living and unspeakably holy God, Who purposefully created me and calls me to Himself to show Himself strong and glorious.


"For the grace of God that bringeth salvation hath appeared to all men, Teaching us that, denying ungodliness and worldly lusts, we should live soberly, righteously, and godly, in this present world; Looking for that blessed hope, and the glorious appearing of the great God and our Saviour Jesus Christ; Who gave himself for us, that he might redeem us from all iniquity, and purify unto himself a peculiar people, zealous of good works" (Titus 2:11–14).

Sunday, June 2, 2013

The Worship-Gospel Continuum


  1. What is your Worship focus? (John 4:23–24)
    Do you think more about Who God Is (Spirit and Truth) than about doing the right things? Do you think more about God than even good things, like singing praise and engaging other people?
  2. What is your Gospel message? (I Corinthians 2:2)
    Do you talk more about Who Jesus Is than about what He gives us? Do you talk more about Jesus than even good things, like love and grace?
I've been thinking about this a lot. Probably too much, since it resulted in a visual. The horizontal line represents how we worship God. The vertical line represents how we speak the Gospel. Every person and every denomination fits somewhere on this chart.
  • In the upper-left quadrant is the Christian's goal: worshiping God in spirit and in truth and proclaiming Jesus Christ.
  • In the lower-right quadrant is the majority of religious beliefs: people looking for goodness, peace, and unity, but neglecting the Bible, the Holy Spirit, and the Lord Jesus Christ (the epitome of all that they desire).
  • In the lower-left quadrant could be New Age teaching, which invites us to have spirituality, truth, and goodness without Jesus Christ.
  • In the upper-right quadrant might be Post-Modern Christianity, which preaches Jesus Christ as a means of uniting people of all faiths and lifestyles. As long as you're sincere, you're in.
Someone could argue that the biblical ideal is in the very center of the chart, at the intersection of Worship and Gospel. I think, however, that the center is where we find the lukewarm church, mixing human efforts with the biblical ideal. True goodness, sincerity, and tolerance are fruits of seeking God, not targets in and of themselves.

There are infinite varieties of beliefs, but my point is, each one has a goal for their gospel and worship.

What are your goals?

Monday, May 13, 2013

Hath God Said?

"[In the song's lyrics, the] biblical emphasis that 'the glory of the Lord shall be revealed' had been changed to how 'we shall see' his glory. This is not nitpicking, for the same inversion characterized all the worship choruses that day. The focus was on us, instead of on God and what he reveals. Such worship fosters the basic perspective that faith depends on how well we notice God's glory, rather than on the gift of God's revelation that God's grace enables us to receive."

— Marva Dawn, Reaching Out without Dumbing Down
Subtle Scripture inversion, as described above by Marva Dawn, is all over today's Christian music, and it is particularly well masked in the modern hymns movement. It is one of the reasons why I have not embraced even the "good hymns" of crossover songwriters, such as Keith and Kristyn Getty. Their songs seem to me to miss the mark of rightly proclaiming God's truth.

I once used the word shallow to describe the "biblically based" and "Cross-centered" lyrics in this movement; I stand by that description, despite some raised eyebrows. While the lyrics allude to a broad range of biblical/gospel texts and themes, the wording still presents a superficially self-focused theology/doctrine. Broad is not the same as deep, hence, shallow.

It is shallow because it has a one-track view of God's:
  • Character ("God loves ME!"),
  • Works ("He did this for ME!"), and
  • Honor ("He exalts ME!").
It is shallow because it praises God's gifts and grace but avoids mentioning:
  • Repenting toward God,
  • Turning from sin,
  • Walking in holiness,
  • Sacrificing our lives for God, or
  • Serving others in Jesus' name.
Man-centered worship, though based on biblical themes, is an inversion of true biblical worship. Biblical worship is not about ME being redeemed and glorified through God. Biblical worship is a reverent celebration of GOD, in Christ Jesus, reconciling the world to HIMSELF.

Studying the biblical Psalms can help develop our sensitivity, awareness, and responses to God's:
  • Holiness ("Let them praise Thy great and awesome name"),
  • Creation and Redemption ("Let us kneel before the LORD our Maker"), and
  • Sovereignty ("Let men say among the nations, The LORD reigns").
If it were easy to spot Scripture inversion, it wouldn't deceive us. But it is difficult to see, and it is even more difficult to explain the danger to someone who's convinced there isn't any deception (and doubly convinced if a song appears to quote Scripture).

This, however, is preservation of biblical truth at a very basic level—how we receive and understand God’s Word. Twisting the truth was Satan’s first tactic in tempting Eve to sin: Did God really say what you think He said?

May the Holy Spirit teach us to say with Jesus, "It is written."

Related Articles

It appears that I’m still exploring the question: How MUCH can we rearrange God’s truth before it becomes untruth? See Discerning Poetic Truth.

Monday, August 6, 2012

Tim Keller’s Evangelistic Worship


‎“There are eternal consequences resulting from all our thoughts, words, and actions, of which we take far too little account” (J. C. Ryle).
I have read Tim Keller’s 2001 article Evangelistic Worship a number of times, and what I get out of it is a deep concern for where his philosophy of worship and evangelism will take him and those he influences.

There is a growing trend in the evangelical Christian community to reshape the true Gospel, to make it more palatable to the unbelieving. More and more we preach Grace, Love, Tolerance, Freedom, and Acceptance and minimize simple preaching of the only God and Savior, Jesus Christ.

Here is Tim Keller’s gospel, in his own words:
“The Bible’s purpose is not so much to show you how to live a good life. The Bible’s purpose is to show you how God’s grace breaks into your life against your will and saves you from the sin and brokenness otherwise you would never be able to overcome… religion is ‘if you obey, then you will be accepted’. But the Gospel is, ‘if you are absolutely accepted, and sure you’re accepted, only then will you ever begin to obey’. Those are two utterly different things. Every page of the Bible shows the difference.” (source)
Where is Jesus in this gospel?

The true purpose of the Bible is to reveal Jesus Christ as God. The gospel is not what God did or does to jumpstart our broken lives. It’s not about us. The gospel is Jesus Christ glorifying God in human form, which mankind was incapable of doing before Jesus came to earth and is still incapable of doing apart from Him. The gospel, according to the apostles and first disciples, claims Jesus as the only God, Creator, Law-Giver, Covenant-Maker, Redeemer, and King of the universe. The gospel (“good news”) is Who Jesus Christ Is. That is what makes the things He has done and the things that He gives us so incredibly amazing.

Our understanding of the gospel will directly influence our worship practices.

Shifting the gospel message a fraction of an inch away from Jesus Christ is a huge step in the wrong direction. Even Christian things, such as loving our neighbor, extending grace, or preaching the Bible, are iniquity (self-will) if they displace Jesus Christ as our chief message, model, motivation, and means of glorifying God. If we are not laser focused on exalting Christ, our greatest “Christian” ideas and beliefs will fail in the end to give glory to God.
“If Christ is not first with you, Christ is nothing to you” (C. H. Spurgeon).
Keller’s Evangelistic Worship model, using a combination of the Bible, the cultural context of our communities, and the historical tradition of the church, is not actually Christ-centered or spiritually safe way to determine our worship practices.

The Bible is infallible, but we are not. It is easy to read into the Scriptures what we want it to say and mean. We routinely “quote mine” the Bible for verses that seem to support a particular point of view or doctrine, sometimes blatantly overlooking the original context and application intended by God. If we read the Bible with our own agenda up front and center, we will inevitably stray from The Truth (Jesus Christ).

Cultural context is unstable ground on which to build any sort of Christian worldview. If you hold the Bible up to the mirror of culture, you will read the Gospel backwards every time. The Bible is meant to be the mirror, allowing us to see ourselves and our culture as God sees us, from His point of view.

Historical tradition may be useful, but it can also be greatly misleading if viewed through the wrong filters. Tradition has a way of feeding upon itself and becoming more important to us than God and His Word. So much depends on:
  • what parts of history we look at,
  • whose tradition we are inclined to believe,
  • how far back we look,
  • what worldview we use to interpret the facts, and
  • what filters we use to apply what we learn in a different context (such as today’s culture).
But the Bible and history are useful, because they reveal God’s holiness, His unchanging nature (immutability), and how He has worked in generations past. The Bible helps us to understand man’s natural depravity and shows us how to know and love God through Jesus Christ. History help us to identify and avoid the sins of previous generations and to continue doing the good works of the righteous.

Does the church need to adopt a post-modern culture to preach the Gospel in a post-modern society? Biblically, historically, the answer is No. The first-century Jewish Christians did not become Gentiles in order to tell the Gentiles about Jesus. They did, however, break with Jewish tradition (not Biblical law) to eat with Gentiles who received the gospel.

We have not been called to pander to the people we want to evangelize and bring into the church. We, God’s people, are called to be witnesses of Who Jesus Is, and what He has done, and what we have seen Him do.

Authentic Christianity—the Spirit of God at work in the lives of His people and their shared joy in Him—transcends cultural and even language barriers. The most “with-it” preacher won’t change worldly-minded people without the truth of God’s Word and the power of the Holy Spirit. But the inspired Word of God, living and powerful and sharper than any two-edged sword, spoken in love by the hokiest of preachers (“the foolishness of preaching”), has transformed the most unlikely people.

In Tim Keller’s practical “evangelistic” worship model, the Lord God—His Spirit, His truth, His will, His pleasure, His character—is hardly given lip service, let alone shown to be the central focus, the main criteria and object of our worship. The One Who created both worship and worshipers. Perhaps it was too obvious for him to mention, but for me it is too important to overlook.

The more we focus our worship to model, exalt, and glorify the Lord Jesus Christ, the more truly evangelistic we will become. Jesus promised to draw all people to Himself (John 12:32). Therefore, as our worship exalts Him (“lifts Him up”), we may trust Him to have a positive evangelical effect on His own lost people.
“But he that glorieth, let him glory in the Lord. …But I fear, lest by any means, as the serpent beguiled Eve through his subtilty, so your minds should be corrupted from the simplicity that is in Christ” (II Corinthians 11:17, 12:3).

Thursday, July 26, 2012

Unifying Worship

Ideas Trend

Here is a corollary to Richard Weaver’s proposition that “ideas have consequences.” Not only do ideas have consequences, ideas don’t stand still. Ideas move relentlessly toward their point of focus, taking the path of least resistance.

In the world of Christian music it often plays out this way:
A church leader has an idea to bridge his congregation into more contemporary music, teaching them his own caveats and specific guidelines. A few decades later the church is indistinguishable from the world in its musical presentation. Their initial goal was to incorporate fresh new styles into the church and the church has trended in that direction. The new leaders see nothing wrong with their worship style, but they do wonder why so many young adults are leaving the church to pursue sinful lifestyles.

Another, increasingly common, scenario goes like this:
A church leader has an idea to repackage the Gospel to appeal to his own community, teaching the things of God through a culture-oriented style. A few decades later the church values self-expression in worship more than the Word of God. Their initial goal was to build upon people’s natural interests and strengths and the church has trended in that direction. The new leaders see nothing wrong with their worship practices, but wonder why so many people struggle with sin habits and need more and more counseling.
In developing our ideas of worship music, a vital question to ask is, “What is our point of focus?”

If we focus on music style—be it conservative, contemporary, or a crossbreed of the two—we will eventually lose sight of what is truly important. The point of worship is not style. It is not traditional, conservative, contemporary, experimental, cultural, blended, or anything like that.

Our GOAL for worship is not to uphold a style.
Our OBJECTIVE in worship is not to engage people.

And the point of discussing worship music is NOT to:
  • agree to disagree.
  • create lists of “acceptable” songs that meet some technical criteria.
  • find a style that everyone tolerates.
  • incorporate or defend a style.
  • reach people using “their” music.
These ideas—which crop up in every Christian music discussion and debate—are so much static obscuring the real issue.

The HEART of worship, the OBJECT of worship, the REASON we worship is so obvious we hardly ever stop to think about it.

Jesus Christ Alone

The whole point, object, focus, and meaning of worship is the LORD God, Who is revealed in the person of the Lord Jesus Christ, Who is made known to us by His Holy Spirit. This is what separates and isolates Christianity from all other religions and unites us. We believe that Jesus Christ is the only living God and that He alone forgives our sins by grace through faith, not by our own works of righteousness or human wisdom.

The ONLY unifying goal and object of worship that we have is the Lord Jesus Christ. There is nothing else in Christendom or on earth that can bridge our differences. (If we think there is, we are being badly misled.)

Jesus calls His followers to unite together in love—to the point of being defrauded of what is rightfully and lawfully ours (I Corinthians 6:7; Romans 14). Unity requires loving sacrifice, humility, and mutual submission.

But in the bonds of unity and love we are also called to teach, remind, warn, and rebuke one another. Just “accepting” one another and tolerating whatever happens in corporate worship will not unify us, nor edify God’s people, nor build up the Body of Christ, nor grow our faith/trust in God. Sometimes we need to gently remind each other to return to our First Love, Jesus Christ.

Passive Christianity results in religious bondage (cults).
Uninhibited Christianity results in religious tyranny or anarchy.

True unity and love are only found in Jesus Christ. The Bible promises God’s people will be conformed into Christ’s likeness (Romans 8:28–29). This promise is our only hope of achieving true unity.

Behold, Unity

“But if we walk in the light, as he is in the light, we have fellowship one with another...” (I John 1:7).
Jesus Christ is the ultimate inspiration, example, model, instructor, and judge of everything that is creative and beautiful.
  • Does our music trend toward Jesus Christ at every level?
  • Do we consciously seek to exalt HIM and emulate HIS character in the words, tone, emotion, performance, and defense of our favorite music?
  • What is He like?
  • What is His nature and character?
  • What does He like and dislike?
  • What are His motives?
  • What does the Bible say about Him?
  • Does our worship music fitly represent Who Jesus Christ Is?
  • Will the world know from our musical witness that in Him is no darkness at all? (I John 1:5)
These are the kinds of questions that are rarely (if ever) discussed when Christian leaders seek to define Biblical worship practices. Why is this not our first line of reasoning? Is Jesus too basic? Too esoteric? Too unrealistic? Too theoretical? Too unrelated? If so, there is a bigger problem than a difference of opinion over worship styles.
“But I fear, lest by any means, as the serpent beguiled Eve through his subtilty, so your minds should be corrupted from the simplicity that is in Christ” (II Corinthians 12:3).
In our quest to glorify God and to worship Him in Spirit and in truth, may the Lord Jesus Christ be our preeminent inspiration.

Saturday, May 19, 2012

Dark Christianity

I don’t get it.

Oh, I hear where they’re coming from.

But I don’t understand why so many professing Christians choose to adorn themselves and their message with uber-casual attitudes, unyielding rebellious spirits, a self-centered youth culture, a dark atmosphere, painfully loud music, hooded eyes, and in some cases tattoos and piercings.

They look like they need the Gospel.

They claim to preach it.

I understand their mission, but I reserve the right, in Christian love, to disagree with it.

They are trying to be both dark and light:

  • Dark so they win the confidence of the world to themselves.
  • Light so they can bring the world to Jesus.

Does it work that way?

The Lord Jesus Christ has always been divisive, a polarizing Spirit of Grace and Truth. In Him is no darkness at all (Job 34:22; I John 1:5). True light drives away darkness. Light cannot successfully masquerade as darkness. Those who love the darkness and hate the light (and vice versa) won’t be fooled by the charade.

Perhaps some people would call a Christian's dark side “salt.” But salt that has lost its distinctive flavor is no longer salty. It’s a dead chemical compound. It looks like salt, but it tastes like nothing, and is good for nothing. (See Matthew 5:13.)

"Let your Christianity be so unmistakeable and your walk so straightforward, that all who see you may have no doubt whose you are and whom you serve" (J.C. Ryle).

Love God and love your neighbor enough to witness to the only True Light. Walk in the light as HE is in the light.

Friday, October 29, 2010

What is Christian Music?

When you’re talking with someone, what is more important:
  1. Your words? or
  2. Your tone of voice?
I think you’ll agree that your tone of voice is just as important as your words (cf Proverbs 15:1). Both words and tone convey meaning.

By the tone of your voice sensitive phrases, such as “I love you” or “I’m sorry,” can convey anything from friendly bonding to hostile sarcasm, from deep commitment to flighty effervescence.

Your tone reveals the intention of your words.

The Language of Sound

If tone can convey meaning ... why are so many people convinced that Christian music is only determined by the words? Do musical tones have less power to convey intention, meaning, and emotion than speaking tones?

Not at all. Music mimics, exaggerates, and ornaments the tones and patterns of our spoken languages.

Musical tone can reveal the intention of the lyrics. Music can even convey ideas without using lyrics. Musical tones can convey every emotion from love to hate, joy to sorrow, peace to chaos.

Music can convey evil ideas as easily as it can convey righteous ideas. By the tone of the music, “I love you” lyrics can mean anything from unending devotion to selfish gratification.

Because tone carries meaning, there must be more to Christian music than setting a Scripture-rich text to a backdrop of sound. It is not enough to have good lyrics. If the tone of the music is lacking spiritual grace, it will undermine the most powerful gospel words.

The sounds that carry lyrics (and music that has no lyrics) must also conform to the Word of God.

Proclaiming Christ

Musical sounds move our human emotions. Further, they can shape our human emotions. This is why movies have soundtracks—they give us clues on how to feel and respond to the story being told.

Church music leaders have a huge responsibility to rightly direct the musical worship of God's people. Their job involves more than merely "picking the songs." They select the music that gives us clues on how to feel and respond to the Story being told.

Selecting, creating, presenting excellent Christian music is a gift of grace, freely given for God's glory to those who humbly:
  • know the Lord Jesus Christ,
  • hear His word/voice, and
  • follow His ways.
I suggest that truly Christian music (i.e., that which follows Christ) will be recognized by its:
  • self-control and gentleness (whether loud or quiet),
  • honor and endurance (having lasting appeal and beauty),
  • dignity and reverence (preserving that which is sacred).
The words will reflect the sounds, and the sounds will reinforce the words.

Christian music that is faithful to the Bible will proclaim the Lord Jesus Christ in fractals—at every level: words, melody, harmony, rhythm, tonal color, artistry, and staging.

Some Characteristics of the Lord Jesus Christ Common Characteristics of Contemporary Music
Love
unselfish; giving
Intimate, Sensual Draw
breathless “come hither”
Joy
cheerful; calm delight
Discontented, Introspective Melancholy
I want; I wish; whiny voice
Peace
at one; united; in harmony
Chaotic Noise
whanging guitars; unnatural sounds, distorted amplification
Patience
enduring; by ext., skillful
Dissatisfaction
unrestful energy; a sense of loss at conclusion
Gentleness
refined; courteous
Incessant Overpowering Beat
driving rhythm; racing tempo, without rest
Goodness
virtuous; righteous
Angry-Sounding Tirades
piercing, maniacal, shrieking
Faith
moral conviction; constancy
Suppressed Melody
no obvious singable “song”; sliding pitches
Meekness
yielded power; yielded to God
Emotional Control
sweeping highs and lows; repetitive unresolved endings
Self-Control
temperate, moderate, balanced
Excessively Loud and Brash
false excitement; overenthusiastic; frenzied

Monday, December 31, 2007

Discerning Poetic Truth

(This is not a comprehensive study of what makes good church music, but a small attempt to better understand evangelical Christian hymn texts, leaving much room for further study.)


How far do you trust a hymn text?

A Christian raises his Bible and says, "This is the Word of God and I trust every word in it." Then he thumps his hymnal and says, "This is the next best thing to the Bible. There’s not a bad hymn in this book."

This makes me nervous. While we can (and should) trust God’s Word, we must still exercise discernment—both spiritual and mental—toward the Bible, to make sure we understand its truth in context. Similarly, while it is Scriptural to sing hymns,
“Not all hymnody is great hymnody. … Even the best hymnals include a few pieces of questionable value to appease certain members of the editorial committee or to make the book more marketable. In other words, even though one may discover a song in a reputable hymnal, it does not necessarily follow that the song itself will be great or that it will even be a hymn” (Paul S. Jones, Singing and Making Music, p. 110, P&R, 2006).

Biblical discernment and sometimes just plain common sense, instructed by the Holy Spirit, are necessary ingredients for Christian Bible study and worship.

Hymns, Poetic License, & Higher Criticism

How much “poetic license” is acceptable in a hymn text? Is it okay to embellish Scripture for the sake of creating larger, more vivid word pictures?

My friend used to chide me for fussing over things that are “not salvation issues.” (Hymns being one of those things.) She always saw the big picture, black and white. I, on the other hand, see little things that if left unchecked can result, over time, in major personal compromise and fission in the Body of Christ.

We balanced each other well, that friend and I.

I do try to look at the big picture of a hymn before criticizing the odd phrase or two. This gives me time to understand an author’s beliefs and intention before passing judgment on the doctrinal content. I examine hymn texts on four levels:

Theme: As with any writing, one phrase or verse of a hymn is not an island unto itself. I may need to read ALL the verses of a hymn to appreciate one phrase. For example, the first verse of “A Mighty Fortress Is Our God” (Martin Luther) ends with a rather depressing thought, “On earth is not his [our ancient foe’s] equal.” But the hymn in its entirety tells the story of our Lord’s triumphant victory to a climax of everlasting joy. (It gives me chills every time.)
Context: Some hymns were written for a specific context and may rely on outdated presuppositions (e.g., social influences of the time). Taken out of its original context, a hymn may easily be misunderstood. Hymn histories and biographies are an excellent (and enjoyable) means to help me understand original context and the philosophies of past generations. Published sermons, if available, can also be helpful.
Meaning: The English language is fluid. Word meanings constantly expand and change due to shifting cultural influences. Sometimes I may need a contemporary (i.e., old) dictionary or Bible version to understand what a hymn writer meant by what he wrote years ago.
Wording: I get caught up in wording, rejoicing at a cleverly turned phrase or mocking overblown professional jargon. But I’m not a great poet, nor do I have a burning passion for poetry (well, except for limericks and parodies). Reading hymns and poetry helps me learn to endure accept and appreciate more flowery phraseology than I would use myself. Forsooth.

Rightly Dividing the Word of Truth

A good hymn text will be Biblical: it will communicate truth from the Bible, and its ideas and expression will be in accordance with the Bible. This definition is two-fold:
  1. It will communicate truth from the Bible. Although it may not directly quote the Bible, every hymn should have a clear Biblical reality. It should be about God, revealing truth about His character and recalling His mighty acts in heaven and earth.
  2. Its ideas and expression will be in accordance with the Bible. A hymn text should assume the Biblical tone toward a holy God and spiritual truth. In speaking of the Lord’s worth and works, His attributes and acts, even a joyful hymn should have a certain weight and discretion (as opposed to lightness and sentimentality).
While many believers may subscribe to this Biblical standard, in actual practice hymns used in church worship often miss the mark:

Not All Who Say, “Lord, Lord”

Many hymns want to praise God. They express this desire then neatly walk all around the subject while revealing a self-absorbed worldview. Their themes may be Biblical but have a skewed perspective; for example, rejoicing in man’s redemption rather than in the Redeemer. This subtlety may not seem important enough to observe or correct, but it can have a subliminal effect on church theology (“me-ology”).

Almost Persuaded

Some nice sounding religious “hymns” actually have little or no Biblical authority whatsoever. These flourished after Darwin published his book on evolution. Social reform was huge and poets urged people to humane efforts to help and protect creation. God was seen as the indulgent Father of all mankind and Christ our Brother was a good man and a great philosopher. (*See note below.) Such humanistic theology infiltrated the church and slowly undermined a proper reverence toward the things of God.
[*Note: I am not denying that God is our Father or that Christ Himself called us His brethren. (See Malachi 2:10; Galatians 4:6; Hebrews 2:11; Romans 8:15, 29.) But the benefits of these relationships are exclusively for humble believers, not for the human race at large—although all are called to repent and be adopted.]

The Voice of Praise

But—thanks be to God!—many godly hymns beautifully communicate a Biblical worldview: a holy God, the natural depravity of unregenerate mankind, and the perfection of the Lord Jesus Christ. These hymns reveal the genuine worship of a believer and the humility that comes from knowing the Creator Who made us. They strengthen us in our faith and in the knowledge of God and His Word.

Taking an absurdly strict (and censorial, and critical) view, it is possible to find errors in hymn texts where none actually exist. A Biblical idea turned sideways for poetic purposes will not change a correct worship of God (in spirit and in truth), nor adversely affect our sincere understanding and application of Biblical truth. The Lord perfects our faith when we diligently seek Him, not when we think we know all the right things.

Finally, while we can and should learn doctrine from hymns, we should not build our theology upon hymn texts alone. We must bring all our thoughts to the Word of God, our sole authority for Christian faith and practice, and pray for wisdom to discern what is true.
~
How firm a foundation, ye saints of the Lord,
Is laid for your faith in His excellent Word!

(“K” in John Rippon's A Selection of Hymns, 1787)